Skip to main content

Talk to us

Business Inquiries
Aaron Blank
CEO & President
+1 206.200.0103
Fearey Offices
1700 Westlake Ave N, Suite 200 Seattle, WA 98109
+1 206.343.1543
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Tracking Your Company’s Social Media ROI

Want more of this?

Sign up for our newsletter and get cutting-edge communications and marketing insights delivered to your inbox.

Social Media ROI, Yes It’s A Thing A common mistake we see from people when planning their social media strategy or campaign is to focus on what are known as vanity metrics. These are metrics that look good, such as the number of followers or likes, but that don’t help the business’ bottom line and […]

Social Media ROI, Yes It’s A Thing

A common mistake we see from people when planning their social media strategy or campaign is to focus on what are known as vanity metrics. These are metrics that look good, such as the number of followers or likes, but that don’t help the business’ bottom line and have no real ROI. We’ve been in more than one business meeting where a C-Suite executive or social media manager has wanted to put their social media ad budget behind fan or follower growth to hit a certain number. It’s our job to help them understand why that isn’t (usually) the best plan and what would be a better way to hit their goals with some help from social media.

Fearey offers free social media assessment


Why the Number of Fans or Followers is Not as Important

Sure it might look good to see 10,000 or 30,000 fans, but are those people seeing the content that you share? Are they your target audience? Are they taking action that is important to your business?

We have a lot of these stories, but here is one that illustrates the point above. Not too long ago I helped a business whose target demographic was men ages 35 – 60, with a household income of $350,000+ living east of Seattle from Lake Washington to Spokane, WA, with a specific set of interests.  However, their Facebook audience was primarily men in their 20s living in the Seattle area and probably not at that income level. This company had a full-time employee creating content for Facebook, receiving little to no engagement and having no idea if or how this was impacting their business.

What to Do?

Check to see if your followers and fans are the people that you need to be marketing to. Are they your target demographic? If not, start targeting the correct people with content that will resonate with them in a way that they want to become your customers, clients, patients or students.

Identify the goals of sharing a social media post. Is it to build brand awareness, sell something, gather new leads? Once you identify your social media goals, set up promoted posts or ads that help you meet those goals and make sure you are targeting the correct people.

Can You Verify It’s Working?

Popular social media sites such as LinkedIn, Facebook, Instagram and Twitter have tracking codes that can be installed on your website to track the actions people take once they arrive from your promoted content. Thus, you’ll know if they are putting stuff in their cart and checking out, starting a wish list, signing up for your newsletter or taking other important actions to measure the ROI of your work.

We once worked with a business who was running a Facebook campaign to gather sign-ups for a service. They had emails, direct mailers, organic Facebook posts, and paid Facebook posts all directing people to the same landing page with no way of knowing where the people who signed up came from. They thought their paid Facebook campaign was doing great because it had tons of clicks. They had put hundreds of dollars into it and reported success to their higher ups with link clicks as their proof of success. We asked if they knew how many people filled in the sign-up form once they got to the landing page from Facebook – they didn’t.

We installed the Facebook tracking pixel to measure the results of their ad and after 10 days of running the campaign and tracking it with the pixel, there was only one sign-up. They had reached almost 5K people and nearly 200 people clicked the link during that time with only one person signing up once they saw the form.

Why was this? Well, their web form was not mobile optimized and over 82% of the people they reached had been from a mobile device. The one sign-up they received was from a desktop visitor. The Facebook ad leading visitors to the landing page had very limited information on it and once people got to the website and read all the details, including the cost, they may have been turned off.

What did we do? We set up a lead generation ad on Facebook instead, which included all the details including the cost and we simplified the form so there were fewer fields to fill out. The results of this were almost 50 leads at a cost-per-lead that was 18% of the cost of the one lead they received from their link click campaign.

TAFT – Test, Analyze, Fix, Test

We like to follow the TAFT system for social media content, especially ads, even though TAFT has absolutely nothing to do with social media. It is a reliability growth analysis testing system to identify problem areas and improve on them when developing new products. Basically, we try something then analyze its performance, identify what could be better (ex. lower cost-per-click, more leads), make some changes (ex. update copy, switch out images, drill down the targeting) and test it again. While we often hit a sweet spot and exceed our goals, social media is ever-changing and there are always new things to try and new hoops to jump through.

Just last week I set up a few audiences on Facebook for a client and reviewed the estimated people that we could reach with ads. Two days later I went into onto Facebook Ad Manager to see if a potential interest was available to add to those audiences and there was an alert saying that some of the targeting I had set up was no longer available.

Facebook Targeting Audience Alert
Facebook, always keeping you on your toes!

How We Can Help

We understand that social media can be complicated, which is why we are here to help. Sign up for a free 30-minute assessment of your social media channels to find out how your business is performing, what is doing well and where there is room for improvement. No strings attached. As our senior social media strategist at Fearey, I will be here to get you started so that you can effectively measure your social ROI and ensure that your marketing efforts translate into meaningful conversions.

Sign Me Up

 For a more in-depth analysis, including a competitive audit, developing a robust social media strategy or launching a social media campaign for your business, contact us. Let’s get social over coffee! Hopefully, we’ll have some good engagement and end up liking each other in real life so The Fearey Group can guide your social media to help achieve your business goals.

Want more social media insights? Check out our previous blog post on Facebook’s New Template Feature Launch

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.